Replacement cost vs actual cash value
Two ways a property policy can pay a claim, why the difference can be thousands of dollars, and how to tell which one you have.
When something you own is damaged, there are two common ways a property policy can pay. The words are replacement cost and actual cash value. They sound alike, but they can change your claim payment by a lot.
The simple definitions
- Replacement cost pays what it costs to replace the item with a new one of similar kind and quality, without taking off for age or wear.
- Actual cash value pays the replacement cost minus depreciation. Depreciation is the value lost through age and wear.
An example
These numbers are only an example. A storm destroys a playground set. A new one costs $10,000. The set is seven years old, and the policy treats it as having lost 40 percent of its value to age and wear.
- With replacement cost, the policy pays up to $10,000 for a new set, less your deductible.
- With actual cash value, the policy pays about $6,000, less your deductible. You pay the rest of the cost of a new set yourself.
Watch for this. Some replacement cost policies pay the actual cash value first, and pay the rest after you have actually replaced the item. Ask how and when you get the full amount.
Which one should you choose?
Replacement cost usually costs more, but it can protect you from a large gap after a loss. Actual cash value can have a lower price, but you carry more of the risk. The right choice depends on your budget and on how hard it would be to replace the item out of your own pocket.
Other things to check
- Limits still apply. Replacement cost pays up to your limit. If the limit is too low, you can still come up short.
- Some items are treated differently. For example, some policies pay roofs on an actual cash value basis. Ask about roofs and other special items.
- Your deductible comes off either way.
Questions to ask your agent
- Is my building paid at replacement cost or actual cash value? What about my contents and equipment?
- Is there any item, such as the roof, that is paid differently?
- Are my limits high enough to replace what I have today?
This article is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Coverage, limits and exclusions differ by policy and by carrier, so always read your own policy and ask us about your situation.
More from the Aleaf blog
Questions about your coverage?
Request a quote online or call us. We will look at your situation and explain your options in plain language.
